Anglers' Bay Cottages and Marina - Cleveland, New York

Nathaniel H.

My wife, son, and I stayed here for the 2024 eclipse. The owner greeted us immediately on arrival and the cabin we rented was right on the water. The view is beautiful and there were things like a fire pit and horse shoes available. The owner gave us suggestions for where to eat, where to get firewood, and was generally very personable.

The cabin itself was plenty of room for us (we rented cabin F) and there were ammeneties like microwave, stove, oven, coffee maker (with coffee available), toaster oven, plates, pans, pots, silverware. We were told that the cabin we stayed at was the last one to get renovations, which would begin later in the week, so I'm not sure my description of the furniture/carpet/etc. would be relevant for future visitors.

We really enjoyed our stay and would happily visit again in the future.

Maxim D.

Surreal fishing lodge with pontoon boat rentals, fishing boats, jet skis and Kayaks + bikes. Pete and hus crew make you feel like family; safety on Lake Oneida is his priority! Tranquil place to sit by the fire pits or BBQ your days catch! Cabins are cool with breath taking views; wonderful for fisherman or family getaways.

Kerry S.

If you have very low standards of cleanliness, then this place is for you. First, let me say that I work in hospitality and am very familiar with this industry, and this is one of the WORST lodging experiences I've ever had. My Dad accidentally booked 3 nights instead of 2, and when he asked for a refund on the third night, he was told no. I understand that it's a business and all, but it's not a big one, and we stayed during the week days which is very different than a weekend stay. A refund would have gone a long way with my father, who is over 70 and lives paycheck to paycheck. We stayed Aug 29-31, 2023 in Cottage F, which is the only cottage to NOT have been renovated. This would have been nice to know at the time of booking, but nothing on the website mentions this, and the owners never mentioned it either (even though there were updated cottages available). They should have offered us an upgrade at check-in, because Cottage F was abysmal. It was falling apart, the couch looked like it came from a frat house, one bedroom smelled like mold and that same bedroom didn't even have a window (which I'm pretty sure is illegal). On top of that, the cottage hadn't been cleaned in some time - cobwebs and dust everywhere, bugs in the ceiling light over my head (I slept in a top bunk), old corn husks in the oven, and the coffee maker still had old coffee in it which was covered in mold. Disgusting. When we told the owners about the filth and the mold, all they said was, "Oh." They never offered to clean it or anything. This was my first time visiting Oneida Lake and if I ever come back, I will find somewhere else to stay. Very disappointing.

Wapiti13

We were a group of 4 seniors on a fish trip, our 3rd year returning. We brought our boats and kept them at Angler Bay docks for the week, going out to fish in A.M. back for lunch and nap(seniors we are) and out for the evening fish. We caught fish every day: walleye, perch, drum, and decent size panfish..|Pete the owner and his staff were very accommodating, one night re-tying our boats to dock during a windstorm which prevented us damage to our boats..|It’s not the Hilton, but very reasonable pricing and has everything you need for fish trip..

Stephen S.

We showed up the wrong week, the week before our reservations due to some confusion and failure to confirm the date on our part. We come every year but switched weeks a few years ago and forgot. Pete said he thinks he is full up and no room for our boats on the dock. We screwed up and now were scrambling to look for somewhere else. Long story short, Pete the owner burned up his phone to see if he could free up a couple cabins. He got us in and even offered to pull rental boats out to fit our boats. We had to change cabins and two of grabbed a days inn room one night till another cabin was available till the next night, then back in a cabin. I have been in sales and marketing my whole career and customer service is always paramount. Pete and his wife went out of their way and saved our trip! Now that kind of service is old school from this 61 year old retired businessman...5 stars. Stephen Sikorsky, Coventry RI

cman2cu

I traveled up from New Jersey with my three teens on short notice and I reserved an available cabin. Due to the rainy upstate climate I lucked out and took an open reservation for a boat rental. Pete was very helpful and professional. Excellent equipment and clean lodging. For a getaway with the benefit of being right on the water I rate this five stars. Yeah, if you want a hot tub, rub-n-tug, and towel service this is not the place for you. If you wave to other boaters, are courteous, and enjoy the water and fishing you have no better choice in the area. Top notch.

Alexander G.

Very friendly and knowledgeable staff. Very pleasant to be around. Glad they had a tackle shop, especially sweatshirts, idk why but it was in the 50s some of these morning and as it was the last week in July I didn't think to pack one. I also picked up a few bottom bouncers that I forgot at home. I thought the boats were in very good condition and very reasonably priced. My father and I had a great time and caught some decent fish as well.

happylakewatcher

Pete was wonderful, we have very little boating experience and he was there to help us all the way. He even came out onto the late to get us when we couldn't get the outboard started. Always very helpful and friendly. Accommodations were great, and enjoyed so many great meals in local restaurants, thanks Pete for you dinner recommendation! This is my second time there, and my girlfriends first and we look forward to coming back again.